Blog
What the bogs preserve
A bog keeps what a dry field loses. Hair, skin, butter, wood, and the bodies of a few people who were put into the peat thousands of years ago. The National Museum’s account is more careful than the legend, and it should be.
Most of what a bog preserves is not a body. It is pollen, sphagnum, and the record of a wet climate. Now and then it is an object: a wooden vessel, a lump of butter, a carved figure. Rarer still, it is a person, with skin and hair still there. The National Museum of Ireland has the Irish finds that can be visited, and the cautions that belong with them. The people in those cases died by violence the Museum regards as deliberate. They are evidence, and they are dead.
Why anything lasts
Peat is what is left when plants die in water and do not fully rot. Teagasc’s account of the mechanism is short: waterlogging restricts oxygen, and decay slows. The Irish Peatland Conservation Council describes a raised bog beginning in a shallow lake where plant material did not completely decompose, until the mass filled the lake and rose into a dome. The Museum’s guide to Kingship and Sacrifice says that, occasionally, bodies are preserved with hair, skin, hands and internal organs intact. Most people who died in Ireland became bone, or nothing. The bog is not a general cemetery.
The same conditions kept other things, and the exhibition sets them beside the bodies: bog butter, including a wooden vessel from Rosberry, County Kildare, the bog in which Baronstown West Man was found; wooden bowls and figures, one of the figures from Corlea, County Longford. The Irish Peatland Conservation Council makes the wider point about blanket bog. The peat stores a record of vegetation, climate and human activity, and it can seal older field surfaces. A body is the archive at its most human. It is not the only archive.
Two finds in 2003
In 2003 two bodies were found during peat extraction and dated to between about 400 and 200 BC. The Museum’s Bog Bodies Research Project, involving specialists in scanning, diet and pathology, led to the exhibition Kingship and Sacrifice at the Museum of Archaeology on Kildare Street. The Museum lists it as free.
Clonycavan Man is the one whose face survived. The Museum’s catalogue entry says workers at a peat works in Ballivor bog, County Meath, found him in February 2003, in a peat-screening machine. He had lain in a deep bog in the townland of Clonycavan, on the Meath–Westmeath border. The machine had damaged him from the waist down. The head was intact. Hair on the chin and upper lip suggested a moustache and a goatee. The haircut was close at the back, about 2.5 centimetres, and the rest, about 20 centimetres, was gathered into a topknot. He was a slight man, about 25 to 40 years old, and about 172 centimetres tall, five feet seven and a half. Analysis of his hair indicated a plant-based diet for the four months before he died. The Museum says he was killed by a series of blows to the head and trunk, probably from an axe, and that a cut about 40 centimetres long on the abdomen may indicate disembowelment. He was naked when found. Linen, the entry notes, might not have survived. The dates given are 392 to 201 BC. The bog lies on the boundary between the ancient kingdoms of Brega and Mide.
Oldcroghan Man was found the same year in County Offaly. The exhibition is organised around both finds. The Museum’s page on Cashel Man, comparing sites, says Oldcroghan Man was deposited in a bog on the boundary of the territory of Tuath Cruachan, overlooked by Croghan Hill, an inauguration place of the kings of the district. The research project’s date bracket for the two Iron Age bodies is about 400 to 200 BC. The guide to the exhibition calls both men victims of human sacrifice. That is the Museum’s conclusion from the injuries and the context. It is a conclusion you can read on the wall at Kildare Street, and it is still an interpretation of damaged remains, not a witnessed event.
Cashel Man, and a correction
On the afternoon of Wednesday 10 August 2011, Jason Phelan, a Bord na Móna worker, found a body while operating a milling machine in Cashel bog, County Laois. The Museum’s account of the next four days is worth reading in full, because it shows both the care and the damage. Archaeologists and conservators, helped by Bord na Móna staff, investigated. At least two metres of peat had already been harvested from the spot. The naked body lay on its right side, legs tightly flexed, head to the south. The milling machine had removed the head, the neck and the left arm. Parts of those were recovered from the milled peat: pieces of jaw and teeth, ribs, a clavicle, vertebrae, skin and hair.
Two hazel rods seem to have marked the place. The body was radiocarbon dated to about 2141–1960 BC, and the peat underneath gave a similar date. Cashel Man died in the Early Bronze Age, around 2000 BC. The Museum says he is the oldest fleshed bog body yet found anywhere. Older skeletons have come out of bogs — it mentions one about 5,000 years old from Stonyisland Bog, County Galway — but they are bone, not flesh.
The injuries have been revised, and the revision matters. Early reports, from the first pathological examination, suggested axe wounds on the back and a broken spine. The Museum now says those are thought to be damage from the milling machine and from the natural compression of the bog. What remains as evidence of violence, in the current account, is a long cut on the lower back and a broken arm. The head, neck and chest, where fatal injuries would most clearly be read, were too damaged by the machine for a cause of death to be settled. The Museum still reads him as a likely victim of the same kind of killing it sees in the Iron Age bodies. It says so, and it also publishes the correction. Both should travel together. A newspaper version that has not caught up with the milling damage is not as good as the Museum’s page.
Cashel bog is on the border of an old territory, Fearann Ua Leathlobhair, under Cros Dubh, which the Museum calls the probable inauguration place of the kings of Laois. That location is why the Museum connects him to Oldcroghan Man, and to a theory of kingship.
The theory, stated as a theory
Kingship and Sacrifice is built around a theory: that certain men were killed and placed in bogs on territorial boundaries as part of rituals of sovereignty in the Iron Age. The Museum says other finds cluster in the same sorts of places: regalia, horse gear, weapons, feasting utensils, boundary markers, quern stones, and bog butter. The theory page names pieces, among them the Petrie Crown, gold collars from Ardnaglug bog in Roscommon, and a bronze cauldron from Ballyedmond in Galway. It is an argument from pattern. The Cashel Man page says the pattern may reach back to the Early Bronze Age. The verb the Museum uses is “suggests.”
Gallagh Man, from County Galway, and Baronstown West Man, from County Kildare, are in the same exhibition, so the finds of 2003 are not asked to stand for every body in the collection.
What the machines did
Clonycavan Man was damaged from the waist down by a screening machine. Cashel Man’s head and one arm were taken by a milling machine. Industrial cutting is why these two were seen, and why parts of them were destroyed before an archaeologist arrived. Read the Museum’s damage notes before repeating an earlier, gorier report. The industrial bogs and the archaeological record are the same ground.
The exhibition is Kingship and Sacrifice at the National Museum of Ireland – Archaeology, Kildare Street, Dublin 2. The Museum says entry is free. Go for the butter, the wood and the boundaries as well as the bodies, and for the label that says which wounds were the machine’s.
The peat they were laid in is the same material later cut for the hearth. A bog that can keep a body for four thousand years has stayed wet and short of air. Cutting it, or milling it, spends that archive as fuel. Where drains are blocked and the surface stays wet, most of what remains will never be a body. It will be moss, pollen, and the carbon store Teagasc and the Irish Peatland Conservation Council describe. The bodies are the part that makes that store impossible to think of as merely soil.
Sources and further reading
- National Museum of Ireland, Cashel Man: museum.ie
- National Museum of Ireland, catalogue entry for Clonycavan Man: museum.ie
- National Museum of Ireland, Bog Bodies Research Project: museum.ie
- National Museum of Ireland, Kingship and Sacrifice exhibition: museum.ie
- National Museum of Ireland, the theory of kingship and sacrifice: museum.ie
- National Museum of Ireland, guide to the exhibition (PDF): museum.ie
- Teagasc, how peat forms where oxygen is short, 19 March 2024: teagasc.ie
- Irish Peatland Conservation Council, raised bogs and anaerobic beginnings: ipcc.ie
- Irish Peatland Conservation Council, what blanket bogs preserve: ipcc.ie